CompanyGraph
Use to find companies where this pattern is active.
Three observations describe the present configuration: operating income has risen across the last 4 year-over-year transitions, gross profit is deteriorating, and EBIT margin sits above the company's own historical median while recent sales growth is below baseline (industry-benchmarked). The operating-income improvement is occurring somewhere below the gross-profit line.
State
Operating income rising with gross profit down and EBIT margin elevated above the company's own median
Emergence
Three observations align: operating income has increased in most or all of the last 4 year-over-year transitions, gross profit is deteriorating over the same span, and the industry-benchmarked composite of margin-elevation-vs-history and growth-deceleration is high. The opposing trajectories of operating income (up) and gross profit (down) place the improvement somewhere below the gross-profit line — overhead, depreciation, or one-off items — while the elevated-margin-with-deceleration configuration is present on the same statements.
Limits
This interpretation identifies tension between the operating-income trajectory and the gross-profit trajectory, plus the elevated-margin configuration. It does not claim that costs were cut in any specific area, does not predict earnings will decline, and does not assess whether the cost mix is sustainable. The operating-income reading is a year-over-year increase count, not a margin measure. The reversion-risk composite records margin-vs-history and growth-vs-baseline; the conventional 'reversion' framing is predictive — the formula records the current setup only. The observations describe a pattern, not its cause.
Screen for Operating Income Up Despite Gross Profit Decline, Margins Elevated
Find stocks where this pattern is currently active in the screener.
Explanation
This diagnostic clarifies a common misreading: Surface reading: Rising operating income suggests a more efficient business. Structural reality: Gross Profit Decreased Year-Over-Year (gross-profit-decreased-yoy-4y) shows the revenue-to-COGS relationship is worsening — the gain is not happening above the gross-profit line. Margins Elevated With Decelerating Growth (margins-elevated-with-decelerating-growth) records that EBIT margin sits above the company's own historical median while recent sales growth is slower than baseline — a present-state configuration, not a prediction. Operating Income Rising (operating-income-rising-4y) counts year-over-year increases in the operating-income line despite the gross-profit weakness, which locates the improvement in expense lines below gross profit. The combination describes where the operating-income improvement is and is not occurring. It does not specify the cause.
Interpretation
Co-occurrence of the operating-income-rising-4y count, the gross-profit-trend reading, and the margin-elevation-with-deceleration composite. The formulas describe trajectories and a configuration; they do not localize cost cuts or test for 'quality reduction'.
Required Observations
Gross Profit Decreased Year-Over-Year (4 years)
Gross profit has decreased year-over-year across the most recent 4 fiscal years.
Margins Elevated With Decelerating Growth
The EBIT margin sits further above its own past level, with growth slowing more, than for most companies in the industry.
Operating Income Increased Year-Over-Year (4 years)
Operating income increased year-over-year in each of the last four fiscal years.