CompanyGraph
Use to find companies where this pattern is active.
Three present-state observations from three published academic frameworks co-occur: the Graham Number (1949 value-investing rule of thumb) places price below its intrinsic-value ceiling; the margin-elevation/growth-deceleration composite is firing; the Beneish M-Score (1999 eight-variable earnings-quality composite, originally designed to flag financial-statement fraud) is elevated. The configuration describes co-occurring model readings; this interpretation does not endorse any of the three models' predictions in our voice.
State
Current price below the Graham Number intrinsic-value estimate, EBIT margin elevated above its historical median while recent sales growth has slowed, and the Beneish M-Score composite is in the upper portion of its industry-benchmarked range
Emergence
Three present-state observations co-occur. The Graham Number model places current price below its intrinsic-value estimate of √(22.5 × EPS × BVPS). The 'margins-elevated-with-decelerating-growth' obs records that current EBIT margin sits above the company's own historical median while recent sales growth is slower than the baseline period. The Beneish M-Score (an eight-variable composite of DSRI, GMI, AQI, SGI, DEPI, SGAI, LVGI, and TATA) is elevated against industry peers in the direction the model flags as anomalous. The configuration places one valuation-model reading alongside two earnings-quality model readings.
Limits
Each obs surfaces a published model's output; this interpretation does not endorse any of the three models' predictions in our voice. The Graham Number formula is a 1949 rule of thumb that embeds fixed P/E (15) and P/B (1.5) ceilings and assumes positive EPS and book value; it may not apply cleanly to growth, cyclical, or asset-light businesses. The 'margins-elevated-with-decelerating-growth' obs records the present configuration of margins and growth; whether or when reversion follows is not claimed. The Beneish M-Score is a 1999 model calibrated on 1982–1992 data, originally designed to flag financial-statement fraud; an elevated score is a model output, not a determination that manipulation has occurred or that earnings will decline. Elevated margins can persist longer than the model anticipates; companies flagged by Beneish are not necessarily restating; companies below the Graham Number can stay there.
Explanation
Each observation is an independent published-model reading: Graham Number (Intrinsic Value Composite) (typeKey 'graham-number') is Benjamin Graham's 1949 intrinsic-value rule of thumb: √(22.5 × EPS × BVPS), where 22.5 = max P/E (15) × max P/B (1.5). A high score means current price is below the model's calculated ceiling. Whether the company is actually undervalued depends on factors (growth, quality, durability) the model does not capture. Margins Elevated With Decelerating Growth (typeKey 'margins-elevated-with-decelerating-growth') records that current EBIT margin sits above the company's own historical median (scaled by MAD) while recent sales growth is slower than the baseline period. The formula records the present configuration of margins and growth, not a directional prediction. Beneish M-Score (Earnings-Manipulation Risk Composite) (typeKey 'beneish-m-score') is an eight-variable composite from Messod Beneish, 'The Detection of Earnings Manipulation' (Financial Analysts Journal, 1999), calibrated on 1982–1992 data. The eight components — DSRI, GMI, AQI, SGI, DEPI, SGAI, LVGI, TATA — span sales growth, margin changes, asset quality, depreciation, leverage, and accruals. The model was originally designed to flag financial-statement fraud. The score is a model output that places the company within a probability distribution; it does not establish the presence or absence of manipulation. The three together describe co-occurring readings from three published frameworks. The conventional 'apparent cheap multiple vs structural earnings risk' framing maps the combination to a coming-decline claim; the underlying formulas record only the present-state model readings.
Interpretation
This interpretation surfaces what three published academic models say about the company at the current snapshot. It does not predict earnings decline, recommend avoiding the stock, or assess true value. Each model has known limitations: Graham (1949) embeds fixed multiples and assumes positive EPS/BVPS; the margin-elevation composite records configuration not direction; Beneish (1999) is calibrated on dated samples and was designed for fraud screening.
Required Observations
Beneish M Score
Composite score of financial ratio anomalies across eight categories
Graham Number
The Graham Number model places this company's current price below its intrinsic-value estimate based on EPS and book value.
Margins Elevated With Decelerating Growth
EBIT margin is currently elevated above its own historical median while recent sales growth has slowed.