Joel Greenblatt

A systematic value approach that ranks stocks by the intersection of quality and cheapness.

Who He Is

Joel Greenblatt is the founder of Gotham Capital, a hedge fund that achieved remarkable returns of approximately 50 percent annually for over a decade. He is also a professor at Columbia Business School and author of several influential books, including "The Little Book That Beats the Market" and "You Can Be a Stock Market Genius."

Greenblatt is known for making value investing accessible. His Magic Formula combines two simple metrics into a systematic approach any investor can apply. Good investing should not require an MBA or Wall Street experience.

Beyond his own investing, Greenblatt has focused on education. Disciplined, systematic investing is accessible—even if most will not have the temperament to stick with it through difficult periods.

Core Investment Philosophy

Greenblatt's approach combines quality and value. He looks for above-average companies trading at below-average prices. Neither quality alone nor cheapness alone is sufficient; both must be present.

His Magic Formula ranks stocks by two metrics: earnings yield (how cheap) and return on capital (how good). Stocks ranking highly on both measures form the portfolio. This systematic approach removes emotion from investment decisions.

He emphasizes special situations: spin-offs, restructurings, mergers, and other corporate events that create mispricings. These situations require research but offer opportunities that passive strategies cannot capture.

Patience is essential. Greenblatt acknowledges that the Magic Formula underperforms the market in many periods. Success requires holding through these difficult stretches without abandoning the strategy.

Patterns He Focuses On

• Earnings Yield — He measures how much a business earns relative to its price. Higher earnings yield means more profit per dollar invested. This identifies cheapness in a comparable way across companies.
• Return on Capital — This measures how effectively a business uses capital to generate profits. High returns on capital indicate quality businesses that use their resources efficiently.
• Combination of Quality and Value — Neither cheap nor good is enough alone. The intersection of both identifies truly attractive investments.
• Spin-off Dynamics — When companies spin off divisions, the new entities often trade at discounts. Institutional selling pressure and lack of attention create opportunities.
• Forced Selling — Index deletions, bankruptcies, and other events force investors to sell regardless of value. These create temporary mispricings for patient buyers.
• Mean Reversion — Valuations tend to return to historical norms over time. Cheap stocks tend to rise; expensive stocks tend to fall. The Magic Formula exploits this tendency.

Example Companies

Systematic Portfolios — Rather than highlighting individual companies, Greenblatt's Magic Formula invests in diversified baskets of highly ranked stocks. The system, not the specific names, generates returns.

Spin-offs — Greenblatt has written extensively about spin-off opportunities. When parent companies distribute subsidiary shares, the resulting entities often trade at discounts before finding their appropriate valuation.

Risk Arbitrage — Early in his career, Greenblatt profited from merger arbitrage situations where announced deals traded at discounts to deal prices. These required careful analysis of deal completion probability.

Limitations and Criticisms

The Magic Formula underperforms frequently. Greenblatt himself notes that it lags the market in five of every twelve months and in many calendar years. Most investors abandon strategies during these difficult periods.

The approach is mechanical and may miss qualitative factors. Accounting quality, management integrity, and competitive dynamics do not appear in the two simple metrics.

As the strategy has become widely known, its edge may have diminished. When many investors apply the same formula, mispricings may correct faster or disappear entirely.

Special situations require expertise most investors lack. While Greenblatt makes the concepts accessible, executing spin-off or restructuring analysis demands time and skill.

What Modern Investors Can Learn

• Combine quality and value — Do not buy cheap junk or overpay for quality. Seek the intersection of both characteristics.
• Use systematic approaches — Rules remove emotion from decisions. Discipline matters more than brilliance.
• Expect underperformance — Every strategy has difficult periods. Success requires persisting through them.
• Look for special situations — Corporate events create mispricings that patient investors can exploit.
• Keep it simple — Complex does not mean better. Simple, disciplined approaches have historically held up well.

Inside CompanyGraph

View this perspective inside CompanyGraph.